Fifteen years ago, I remember when a prefab home went up in my neighborhood. It came in on flatbeds. Its white vinyl siding looked out of place sandwiched between cheerily painted Victorians, and it made the whole block feel a little shabby. I loathed it.
So when I say there are some absolutely adorable prefab houses springing up, and I want one, you know I mean it. And not only are they adorable: they’re efficient. Really, really efficient. From materials, to the kind of quality control available only from a well-managed factory, to installation, these prefabs save on the energy and manpower usually expended in the construction of a new home even before they start saving the homeowner money in monthly bills.
There are a number of businesses out there making a name for themselves. Michelle Kaufmann Designs is one of the biggest. Her homes are sleek and modern, with eye-catching angles and materials—she styles them "eco-luxe". Engineered for the North Carolina climate, Innova Homes LLC streamlines the process while still tailoring to a more traditional aesthetic. The Dwell Home is another: clean, modern designs that you would never know were prefab. Also out of North Carolina. Maybe it’s time to relocate.
Closer to home—for this New England dweller, anyhow—is Massachusetts-based PowerHouse, taking modular to a new level. As one of the few companies striving for affordability along with stellar design, PowerHouse provides an ideal starting place for a discussion of modular green building. Affordability brings with it a whole set of issues and complications that high design modular doesn't have to face. The company is spearheaded by two men whose experience with green building as well as with factory processes make them uniquely qualified to talk about this burgeoning industry.
PowerHouse
PowerHouse is the brainchild of Quincy Vale, who was a major force behind the Massachusetts Technology Collaborarative's Green Buildings Program and Renewable Energy Trust. He grew up around factories. His experience with green building and his familiarity with the systems-built process flashed into one idea: build modular, energy efficient, healthy homes, and make them affordable. And, you know, look nice. Specifically, he wanted to create a green home that looked completely natural on a neighborhood block and was not a high-concept fantasy of steel, glass, and wild angles.
To achieve his ends, Quincy needed someone who could design beautiful homes and who was both experienced in and excited by the idea of green building. He was introduced to John Rossi by a mutual friend, and it didn’t take much time to get the LEED certified architect to come on board. John was intrigued by the challenge, and it was he who dreamt up the superbly designed PowerPod (more on that separately). Together, they “hit upon the concept of harnessing the whole existing industry†of modular building to produce their homes, instead of starting from the ground up. They take existing factory systems and modify them—it’s efficient in the extreme. When Getsolar.com spoke with PowerHouse, we wanted to get the answers to a couple of burning questions.
How is a factory process more efficient than on-site construction?
In normal on-site construction, a crew spends up to a few days on just the foundation of a house. Anything can go wrong here, and frequently does. It’s very difficult to get the foundation perfectly level. If it’s too cold, you can’t even pour the concrete, and then you have to wait about a month for it to cure. Cutting in windows and holes for utilities all comes later. After it’s done, there’s all manner of pins to take out, and patch; a patch covers up a hole, but doesn’t get rid of it. The first mantra of energy efficiency is Seal, Seal, Seal: your basement is a gigantic energy sink.
PowerHouse basements face none of these issues. They come with raceways ready for utilities and outlets, finished windows, a bulkhead. Pretty much everything but the paint. It’s even thermally broken, so that the concrete forming the outside walls is actually separated from the interior walls. This means that temperature fluctuations are kept to a minimum inside the basement, taking pressure off the home’s heating and cooling system.
Standard hurdles in on-site construction are simply out of the picture in a factory, like the weather, or perfectly level pouring. When the prefab foundation gets to the building site, it goes in in literally hours. Two days on site from raw hole in the earth to finished basement. Contractors who have been in the business for decades have a tendency to scoff at the idea of modular, which is only natural (considering its history). But Quincy says, “when they see a foundation that uses less concrete, that’s preinsulated, engineered, preleveled on the inside, and goes in an hour and a half without the rigamorole of setting up forms, using form release agents, and a bunch of other things that have all kinds of problems associated with them over a number of days…their eyes light up. ‘I get it!’
And the foundation is only the beginning. The rest of the process is just as streamlined. From a cost perspective, it’s important to think of all the man hours being saved. Instead of months on the job? Weeks, and not many of those. John sums it up: “It’s not this is an orange, this is an apple. It’s, This is a beautiful glistening orange, and that’s a crabapple."
How difficult is it to incorporate "green" materials into an existing production system?
The original dream for PowerHouse was to build their own factory and processes from the ground up. But they took the more actionable approach of subcontracting out the actual factory work, and ensuring that the management teams they worked with knew exactly what they wanted and had PowerHouse processes down pat. It took a while to develop a good relationship, and involved a brief detour to Canada, but eventually they found a local factory whose management was eager to jump on board. Green prefab is sweeping the building industry, and they didn’t want to get left behind.
A learning curve was inevitable. But with most of the factory’s systems still in place—most of the difference coming from the materials—it wasn’t too steep. Some potential problems turned out to be not problems at all. For instance, PowerHouse wanted spray foam that was efficient and better for the health of the house than the fiberglass the factory generally used; it had the side effect of shortening the total process instead of bogging down the system.
What kind of a premium am I paying on a modular green home?
Looking at the cost of an energy efficient home is like looking at the cost of renewable energy technologies. Payback over the long term is arguably the most important factor in the equation. The goal of green building is to create a house that is healthier for both the environment and for its inhabitants: this is a kind of payback that can hardly be calculated, but it’s not intangible. Better, fresher air? More natural light? It’s raising the standard of living to where it should be for all of us. Then there is the difference in your monthly utility bills, the payback that feels most concrete and is certainly welcome. And let’s not neglect resale value.
All of these advantages aside, forgetting about payback and embedded value, the real beauty of PowerHouse and is that the market price just isn’t that different. Perhaps 10% more than a conventional home of equal size, perhaps less. Yes, you’ll most likely see a difference in up front costs, but not a big one, and the math doesn’t lie. Quincy did a detailed analysis of a PowerHouse in Cambridge. An average family living in the 1,300 square foot townhouse would save about $2000 a year, or roughly $200/month. Set that against slightly higher monthly mortgage payments, and you have relative cost parity. One point to keep in mind is that Quincy did this analysis when oil was under $80/barrel. It’s now closer to $100. Energy prices aren’t going anywhere but up.
Bi-coastal Blu Homes is also based out of Boston. Blu Homes provides "healthy, efficient, and ecologically friendly homes that respect your time and your budget," using high-tech modeling and building systems to make the process of buying a home more convenient and less expensive. Blu makes aesthetically-pleasing homes that have a bit of IKEA's smooth, minimalist appeal--as well as a minimalist price point, with studios and homes going for anywhere between $50 and 350k.
Green homes can cost much more than conventional homes, and that’s what companies like these ones are trying to fight. If they can prove that it doesn’t have to be that way, and bring the industry along with them, it will become a no-brainer for homeowners: Do I get the house that’s the exact same price but will cost more in energy and upkeep? Of course not. Then the idea is that a tipping point will be reached. As Rossi says, “What’s going to happen is the no brainer will start to win, the building codes will follow, and eventually, the houses that get built will be more like this and less like Joe Schmoe’s, and we’ll all be better off."
Prefab: Greenbuild's New Cool